Guide

GTA 6: does the choice in "Hey Arnold!" change what comes next?

GTA 6: does the choice in "Hey Arnold!" change what comes next?

By GTA6 Central editorial team · Missions · Easy · 3 min read · published on

Choose “Up to where I am” first to set the chapter.

One setting for the whole site and the assistant: no spoilers, up to the chapter you have reached, or show everything. Either way, you can open a folded passage with one click.

Cover image: Rockstar Games (for illustration).

The choice that ends "Hey Arnold!", the game's eighth main mission, in chapter 1, changes nothing in the story: the next scene plays out the same way whatever you decide. It only affects your criminal profile. Last checked on November 21, 2026.

For the whole mission, see the "Hey Arnold!" walkthrough; for the profile system, the criminal profile tiers.

What the choice changes

What could changeWhat happens
The next scenethe same either way
The rest of the storynothing changes; the next mission unlocks the same way
The rewardnone, whatever you choose
The criminal profilethe violent option earns a "Hardened" rating; the lenient option a "Restrained" rating
Doing nothingthe game decides after a delay, with the same effect as the lenient option

Steps

  1. See the chase through: by car, then on foot, to the docks. The choice appears at that point.
  2. Pause the game if you're unsure: the choice is timed, and the game decides for you if you take too long.
  3. Choose according to the profile you want: the criminal profile works a bit like an honor system, and it is the choice's only lasting effect.
  4. Keep a manual save if you want to be able to go back: GTA 6 doesn't let you replay a mission.
What happens to Arnold

The choice is to kill Arnold or to spare him. Either way, he leaves the game for good. If you spare him, or let the delay run out, he swims away and disappears; you can't shoot him while he swims. Jason then tells Brian that Arnold won't cause any more trouble, and that's enough for Brian.

Pitfalls

  • Thinking the lenient option will have consequences: it has none in the story. Only the criminal profile keeps track of your decision.
  • Letting the timer run: if you don't answer, the game picks the lenient option for you.
  • Counting on a replay: there isn't one. Without a save made before the mission, the choice is final.
  • Mixing it up with the next mission: "Island Dreams" also has a choice, less obvious. See its walkthrough before starting it.

The other early missions are in the walkthroughs.

Frequently asked questions

Does the choice in "Hey Arnold!" have consequences?

Not on the story: the following scene is identical and the next mission unlocks the same way. It only counts toward the criminal profile: the violent option earns a "Hardened" rating, the other a "Restrained" rating.

What happens if I don't choose in "Hey Arnold!"?

The game decides after a delay, with the same effect on the criminal profile as the lenient option. Pause the game if you want time to think.

Sources and verification

Information from press previews, verified on 21 November 2026.

Report an error or suggest a clarification

Comments(0)

Share your analysis and discoveries. Comments are moderated: stay respectful and avoid presenting rumors as facts.

0/2000

Loading…